All images are AI generated
State violence in India’s coal war is analyzed in new research. Fourteen years ago, police deployed to block villagers from protesting a power plant on coastal wetlands shot at protesters, killing three and injuring hundreds. Two years later, on the other side of the country, a Buddhist monk was killed in resistance to a hydroelectric dam project.
State Violence in India’s Coal War: Uncovering the Hidden Costs of Energy Transitions
Related Video
India, a nation aspiring to achieve net-zero carbon emissions by 2070, faces a stark reality: its heavy reliance on coal as an energy source. This contradiction fuels ongoing debates about energy transitions, justice, and the role of state-sanctioned violence in land expropriation.
State Violence in India’s Coal Transitions: A Deeper Look
Mukul Kumar, an assistant professor of urban planning and public policy, has delved into this complex issue, shedding light on the violent aspects of energy transitions in India. His research, published in Climate and Development, examines 121 coal and hydropower projects in the country.
Kumar’s findings reveal a disturbing pattern: both coal and hydropower energy transitions are characterized by significant state-sanctioned violence. This violence often manifests as police violence, arrests, and even killings of protestors who oppose the expansion of extractive energy industries.
The Case of Coal and Hydropower in India
India’s coal industry, responsible for 70% of the country’s electricity-generating capacity, has been a major driver of economic growth. However, this growth has come at a price. Coal mining and transportation have led to environmental degradation, displacement of communities, and health issues for those living near coal-fired power plants.
Hydropower, often touted as a clean and renewable energy source, has also been marred by violence. The construction of dams has resulted in the displacement of Indigenous communities, disruption of ecosystems, and conflicts over water rights.
The Impact of State Violence on Vulnerable Communities in India
The brunt of this violence falls disproportionately on Indigenous (Adivasi) and frontline communities, including Dalits, landless farmers, and artisanal fishers. These communities, already marginalized and facing various forms of discrimination, bear the additional burden of state violence and land expropriation.
Just Transition: A Call for Reckoning with State Violence in India
India’s Ministry of Coal has recently announced the establishment of a World Bank-financed just transition division. However, Kumar emphasizes the need to address the historical injustices of state violence and land expropriation within the context of both fossil fuel and low-carbon energy transitions.
Just transition policies, which aim to ensure a fair and equitable transition to a sustainable energy future, must acknowledge and repair the past harms caused by state violence. This includes holding police officers accountable for the criminalization of dissent and providing redress for affected communities.
Moving Forward: A Path to True Justice in India’s Energy Transitions
To achieve truly just energy transitions, Kumar urges energy policy makers and researchers to confront the role of state-sanctioned violence and take steps to address its consequences. This includes incorporating mechanisms for redress, such as compensation for victims of violence and the establishment of independent accountability mechanisms.
By repairing and redressing the historical injustices of state violence, India can move towards a more just and sustainable energy future that respects the rights of all communities, especially the marginalized and vulnerable.
Wrapping Up
India’s energy transitions, both in terms of fossil fuels and low-carbon sources, have been marked by state-sanctioned violence and land expropriation. This violence disproportionately impacts Indigenous and frontline communities, exacerbating existing inequalities.
Just transition policies must confront this historical injustice and take steps to redress the harms caused by state violence. By acknowledging and repairing the past, India can pave the way for a truly just and sustainable energy future.
FAQ’s
1. What is the main focus of Mukul Kumar’s research?
Mukul Kumar’s research focuses on the violent aspects of energy transitions in India, particularly in the context of coal and hydropower projects.
2. What are the key findings of Kumar’s research?
Kumar’s research revealed that both coal and hydropower energy transitions in India are characterized by significant state-sanctioned violence, including police violence, arrests, and killings of protestors.
3. How does state-sanctioned violence impact vulnerable communities?
State-sanctioned violence disproportionately affects Indigenous (Adivasi) and frontline communities, including Dalits, landless farmers, and artisanal fishers. These communities often face displacement, environmental degradation, and health issues due to energy transitions.
4. What is the significance of just transition policies in addressing state violence?
Just transition policies aim to ensure a fair and equitable transition to a sustainable energy future. They play a crucial role in addressing state violence by acknowledging and repairing the past harms caused by energy transitions, such as land expropriation and criminalization of dissent.
5. What steps can be taken to achieve a truly just energy future in India?
To achieve a just energy future, India needs to confront the role of state-sanctioned violence in energy transitions and take steps to address its consequences. This includes incorporating mechanisms for redress, providing compensation to victims of violence, and establishing independent accountability mechanisms.
Links to additional Resources:
1. https://www.hrw.org/ 2. https://www.amnesty.org/ 3. https://www.frontlinedefenders.org/.Related Wikipedia Articles
Topics: Energy transition, State violence, Just transitionEnergy transition
An energy transition (or energy system transformation) is a major structural change to energy supply and consumption in an energy system. Currently, a transition to sustainable energy is underway to limit climate change. As much sustainable energy is renewable it is also known as the renewable energy transition. The current...
Read more: Energy transition
State violence
State violence is the use of force, intimidation, or oppression by a government or ruling body against the citizens within the jurisdiction of said state. This can be seen in a variety of forms, including military violence, settler colonialism, surveillance, immigration law, and other tactics used to express authority over...
Read more: State violence
Just transition
Just transition is a framework developed by the trade union movement to encompass a range of social interventions needed to secure workers' rights and livelihoods when economies are shifting to sustainable production, primarily combating climate change and protecting biodiversity. In Europe, advocates for a just transition want to unite social...
Read more: Just transition
